Red poppies are everywhere. For the past few weeks, in tube stations and the streets, you could buy a little red paper poppy to pin on your jacket, to show your respect for the nation’s fallen soldiers in the lead up to Remembrance Day. Today, led by the Queen, politicians laid wreaths at the Cenotaph to honour the soldiers who had died in conflict, while the country observed two minutes of silence.
It’s all very solemn and respectful, but dig a little deeper, and the stench of their hypocrisy rises to the surface.
Here’s David Cameron, proudly wearing his poppy and ‘connecting’ with the Royal Marines. “We must remember forever, not just for today,” he says.
The trouble is, does he remember? Does the nation remember? And what was the purpose of remembering? Was it not to remember the horrors and devastation of war? Was it not to celebrate the signing of the armistice? Was it not to learn from past mistakes, to ensure that present and future generations would never have to go through what our ancestors went through? If Britain’s leaders truly remember, why are they still so committed to militarism? Why have they spent £2 billion developing military drones over the past five years, with plans to spend a further £2 billion, while public services are being mercilessly cut? Why are British arms being sold to support Middle Eastern dictatorships? Why do soldiers continue to kill and be killed in needless wars in Afghanistan?
Or is it simply a sentimental, condescending pat on the head of the fallen and their relatives, a continuation of the glorification of war and violence as a way of resolving disputes? Through the rhetoric of honour and glory, they obscure the horrors and realities of war, and insist on creating new fallen heroes, even as they mourn the old ones.
Ben Griffin, an ex-SAS soldier, says,
“War is nothing like a John Wayne movie. There is nothing heroic about being blown up in a vehicle, there is nothing heroic about being shot in an ambush and there is nothing heroic about the deaths of countless civilians. Calling our soldiers heroes is an attempt to stifle criticism of the wars we are fighting in. It leads us to that most subtle piece of propaganda: You might not support the war but you must support our heroes, ergo you support the war. It is revealing that those who send our forces to war and those that spread war propaganda are the ones who choose to wear poppies weeks in advance of Armistice Day.”
It is worth bearing in mind that, as Laurie Penny points out, “not all of [the soldiers in the first and second world wars] bled willingly, for king and country; some of them simply bled because they had been seriously injured, because their leaders deemed it appropriate for them to die in pain and terror.” For government to talk reverently of “sacrifice” is to hijack the grief of veterans and their relatives to further their own jingoistic propaganda aims.
Despite a decrease in violence over the centuries, we are still in a society that is obsessed with the idea that ‘might is right’. Our national leaders pin poppies to their suits, bow their heads and mourn the fallen, while their hands drip with the blood of all the soldiers and civilians that they have slain, and will continue to slay.
Pingback: NaBloPoMo Day 11: Something Unusual | Teej Rants
Well written, I have struggled with this over the years and you have articulated it very well! I am now married to a Canadian Forces member and been thrust from the British take on Remembrance Day to the Canadian intensity of it. Thanks for writing this. I had to link it in my blog.
Thank you! I read the post on your blog, it was lovely and very moving. Best wishes to you and your husband!
Well said! I saw a tweet where someone said: “You may not agree with war but you can show some respect to the victims and the veterans!” So the poppy campaign is very effective in labelling all critics disrespectful and insensitive to the sacrifices and the suffering. It’s a way of silencing and vilifying critics.
Absolutely! Which is sad, because from what I know of it, that wasn’t the initial intention at all.
this is excellent. I’ve sent it to a few pals!
Not sure if you’ve seen / heard about white poppies? I’ve not seen many of them, as I know some people worry that it’ll be taken as an insult, but they exist. “Those who promote the wearing of white poppies… choose the white poppy over the red often because they wish to disassociate themselves from the militaristic aspects of Remembrance Day, rather than the commemoration itself. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_poppy_%28symbol%29)
Thanks for this; I have heard of it (vaguely) once, and thought it was a nice idea. Not quite sure why people are offended by it!
What a good post! I feel the same way on this day in the United States (it’s called Veteran’s Day here), and the militarism has only escalated, of course, especially since Sept. 11, 2001. This year I spent the entire day grumbling at the media and saying, “Why don’t we have a holiday to honor peacemakers?”
Thank you! I completely agree with the sentiment of your last sentence; if we could only glorify peacemakers instead of fighters, the world would be a much better place.
““not all of [the soldiers in the first and second world wars] bled willingly, for king and country; some of them simply bled because they had been seriously injured, because their leaders deemed it appropriate for them to die in pain and terror.” ”
Don’t forget- and this may be a harder truth for some to admit- that many of those men were the ones shooting and killing other people, and signed up to do just that. They were the reason other families’ sons were dying and bleeding in pain and terror. Why should they be celebrated and not the nurses who were heroically risking their lives to SAVE lives?
Wonderful website you have here but I was wwanting to know if you knew of any community forums that cover the same topics discussed here?
I’d really like to be a part oof group where I can get comments from other knowledgeable people that share the same interest.
If you have any recommendations, please let me know.